Thursday Theology #404
March 9, 2006
Topic: The History of Medical Missions
Colleagues,
This weeks's post is an ellipse--one storyline orbiting two centers. First
center in the ellipse is John Eckrich's review of Christoffer Grundmann's
pioneering historical study of Medical Missions; second center is John's own
pitch for medical missions today. Both author and reviewer themselves constitute a
second sort of ellipse on the personal level as well. Author Grundmann is the
current occupant of the "John R. Eckrich Chair, University Professor in
Religion and the Healing Arts" at Valparaiso University. Reviewer John D.
Eckrich M.D. is the son of the man for whom the V.U. chair is named. For more
biographical data on both John and Christoffer see the final paragraphs of this
post.
Peace & Joy!
Ed Schroeder
Book Review and Commentary--
Christoffer H. Grundmann. Sent to Heal: Emergence and Development of Medical Missions.
University Press of America: Lanham, Maryland. xvi, 375 pp. Paper. US$40.
Reviewed by John D. Eckrich, M.D., Internist and Gastroenterologist, St.
Louis, and Executive Director of Grace Place Lutheran Retreat Ministries.
Dr. Christoffer Grundmann, in this remarkably detailed and utterly
enlightening perspective on medical missions, closes his thesis thusly, "All
(God's people who hear the call of Christ into healing ministry from the Gospel in
Matthew 4:23 and commissioned to us in John 14:12-15) are asked to give a
credible account of the corporeality of salvation in their respective witness, a
witness which will be credible not in what it claims but in what it actually
brings about tangibly. And this should be nothing but life, life in abundance."
This beautiful paraphrase catches the essence of John 10:10, and I believe
sounds the leading trumpet voluntary from the orchestral history of medical
mission work as provided for us in Grundmann's wonderful text to lead us to
mission service in the 21st Century. Abundant life is "whole life," integrated
living, balancing body, mind, spirit, relationships and emotion into vocation
and leisure. This Gospel mantra, defined by Christ himself in Mark 12 for the
scribes and teachers of the law, describes for us the characteristics necessary
to do medical missions in the future.
Medical missionaries need to understand themselves as "whole" people and
approach their task wholistically. They must see the dis-order and dis-ease in
the people they serve wholly. Missionaries must deal with an interactive
matrix of health and disease"physical, spiritual, emotional, relational and
intellectual" all experienced in a milieu of terrorism, biodegradation, and the
very real challenges of Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, atheism and whatever "isms"
the future holds for us. What formidable challenges! How could anyone vaguely
hope to "heal" in this quagmire? Thank God, as Dr.Grundmann exemplifies for
us from history, we do not enter this trying ground on our own. Our ancestral
missionaries model for us the "healing" power embodied in our work because,
and only because, the glorified body and spirit of our Savior resides within us
from our baptism. His whole being makes us whole. We cannot help but succeed!
Why is an historical review of medical missions so important now, and not
just a major intellectual exercise? As Grundmann reminds us, history provides
us the distance and overview of our actions to allow us to be truly critical of
our motives, direction and outcome assessments.
Particularly poignant are the enlightening questions Grundmann asks of 19th
Century missionaries, and which he reminds us are the questions we need to ask
of ourselves today:
What is the "proper task" of medical missionaries?
How does "saving souls" relate to healing diseases and ordering society toward better function?
With scarce money, should it be spent to train and support primarily medical personnel?
Does the explosion of science and technology redefine "life," "salvation," "healing," and "abundant living"?
Does modern medicine compel us to send people resources into dangerous and often unwelcome settings?
Can we really "enjoy" modern culture and medical knowledge without feeling obliged to extend these to "have nots"?
Sent To Heal beautifully explores the multiple layers and parameters of these
questions with focus on the foundations of medical mission work in the 1800's
led by middle European and British advocates, mission societies of Europe and
North America, gender-specific missionary pioneers, geographic mission
stations in Asia, Africa and eastward, and types of mission venues, particularly
hospital and medical clinics, dispensaries and public health initiatives. With
anticipation, we look forward to Dr. Grundmann's promise of a second volume
detailing 20th Century medical mission work with its new challenges and
opportunities. This is most necessary!
Dr. Grundmann sets the table for what I find are the major themes facing us
in the third millennium. Epidemiology, public health and hygiene, preventative
health, the economics of health care distribution and preservation of
ecological resources for health are leading issues for anyone joining the future
medical mission debate.
Practitioners must be trained and must think and treat wholistically. They
must be versed not only in their medical expertise, but anchored in their
spiritual relationship to Christ, with good management, teaching and people
skills. They should be compassionate (theology of the Cross) and continue to bear
the hurts of those they serve as their medical missionary ancestors have modeled
for them.
Finally, from my own perspective and grown out of history and contemporary
trends, I believe great awareness should be given the concept of faith-community
based nursing, what we used to call "parish nursing." This model, forwarded
by Granger Westberg and others, holds real promise not only for North
American peoples, but for all regions of the world. As we have learned that the
"great American doctor" and the "European or American" hospital/clinic
model imposed into foreign cultures may not be so acceptable an entry point to Gospel
ministry today, the simple care, education, health/hygiene-delivery model
offered by faith-based nurses appears to have effective acceptance in many more
societies.
Dr. Grundmann's book is an essential read for all who hear and accept the
call to health and healing ministry. The bibliography alone is worth the price
of admission. But more importantly, this text and references demonstrate for
us how this fascinating and complex cadre of disciplines and medical and
theological topics place medical mission work on firm scientific, sociologic,
theological, and humanitarian footing. This is God-work.
John D. Eckrich, M.D.
Addendum: John R. Eckrich, who glorified Christ in this Valparaiso chair,
led a dedicated Christian life centered in the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod.
He loved the Church and the Church treated him with goodness. His beginnings
were humble and austere in 1920's America -- broken family, poverty of
the depression, night school degree in engineering from Washington University,
St. Louis, business and civic leadership, and finally CEO of The Lutheran
Medical Center of St. Louis.
When the health care and urban environment around Lutheran Medical Center was
spiraling into a formidable future, he was able to transition this great
health resource into a charitable foundation, now actually divided into two
phenomenal organizations: the Lutheran Foundation of St. Louis having
awarded multi-millions of dollars toward myriad health initiatives in St. Louis and the
world; and, Lutheran Senior Services' managers of a multitude of senior
living and health care facilities throughout the central U.S. His four children and
their spouses all work in the health industry and serve their home Lutheran
congregations with vigor. Jack Eckrich rests this day with a Crown of Glory in
the arms of his healing Savior to eternity.
John D. Eckrich, M.D. (John R. Eckrich's son) is a Lutheran physician,
Internist and Gastroenterologist for the past 30 years in St. Louis. From his
experiences as physician to many Lutheran seminarians at Concordia Seminary in
St. Louis, and private physician to many pastors, teachers and LC-MS personnel, he
founded Grace Place Lutheran Retreats. Grace Place offers weeklong retreats
to Lutheran professional church workers, teaching them preventative health and
wellness skills to integrate physical, emotional, spiritual, intellectual and
relational health into their professional ministry and personal pilgrim walk.
In five years, Grace Place has retreated over 650 clergy couples and 150
seminary students, "inoculating" them against unhealthy practices. Dr.
Eckrich was a medical missionary to Slovakia in the 1990's and currently serves as the
medical director and advisor to Dar Al Kalima Health and Wellness Center in
Bethlehem, Palestine.
Christoffer Grundmann has theology degrees from several institutions in his
native country Germany, beginning with the Hermannsburg Mission Academy and
concluding with the standard "double doctorate" for German university professors
with two book-length dissertations. One of them is the book reviewed here.
The second book (still only available in German) deals with the phenomenon of
healing in the so-called "AIC," African Instituted Churches, in southern
Africa. Christoffer was a Lutheran missionary in South India from 1978-83.
During that time he facilitated the first-ever translation and publication of
Luther's Works in the Tamil language. On return to Germany he joined the staff
of the Institute of Medical Missions at Tuebingen as theological consultant and
hospital chaplain. After several academic appointments in Germany, he joined
the Valparaiso (Indiana) University theology faculty in 2001. He is a
sought-after expert in matters of medical missions, faith and healing, healing
and the spirit worlds, and is often elsewhere on the planet for consultations and guest
lectures in these fields.