Thursday Theology #688
August 18, 2011
Topic: A Book Review: Dean Lueking, "Through Their Eyes. A People's View of the Global Church"
Colleagues,
Dean Lueking's face is on my graduation class photo (Concordia Seminary,
1954). We've continued to be "joined at the hip" ever since. Paul Ananth
Tambyah came into Marie's and my life in 2004 when the Evangelical Church in
America [ELCA] sent us to work with the Lutheran Church of Singapore as Global
Mission Volunteers. My spiffy title was "Theologian in Residence." Every
Monday morning was a seminar with pastors and church leaders. Every two
weeks during our stint there we were farmed out to work in/with another
congregation in the LCP. Paul crossed our path when his congregation asked for a
Crossings workshop and we learned what a Lutheran theologian this medical
doctor -- Senior Consultant Infectious Diseases, Physician and Associate
Professor of Medicine at the National University of Singapore and National
University Hospital -- was, and still is. That connection continues. [Even
medically. When I came home from Singapore with some Asian bug, Paul was in on
the consult at Barnes Hospital here in town as experts tried to isolate just
what bug was bugging me. Paul gave them the laundry list to check for. I
got better.] But it is Crossings that has Paul hooked. So much so that he
not only showed up for a Crossings conference here in St. Louis, but he has
also recruited several Asian Lutheran pastors to attend other Crossings
gatherings. Irrepressible, he's got three more lined up to come to our next
conference in January. [You'd be blessed to be there too. The lineup (see our
homepage) is creme-de-la-creme.]
Paul doesn't confine his calling(s) to the hospital. lecture hall and the
Lutheran Church of Singapore. He's a public figure in the life (and
politics?) of his country, a city-state of 4 million people, with an area comparable
to that of metropolitan St. Louis. I got over 21K references when I
googled his name. Check this URL for one sample:
http://www.temasekreview.com/2011/08/08/paul-tambyah-ten-thousand-people-speaking-up-cannot-be-ignored/
For more about Dean Lueking, read what Paul says below.
Peace and joy!
Ed Schroeder
Dean Lueking. THROUGH THEIR EYES. A PEOPLE'S VIEW OF THE GLOBAL CHURCH,
Chicago: Tyra Books. 472 pp. [Purchase info at the end of the review]
Nearly a year ago, Ed Schroeder wrote to me to ask me to write a book
review of Dean Lueking's book "Through Their Eyes" which is ambitiously
subtitled, "A people's view of the global church." I could not resist the offer. I
had met Rev. Lueking briefly when he came to Singapore and had enjoyed his
presentation to Lutheran ministers and lay people at our own church. I did not
know at the time that he was on a global journey that would take him around
the world and result in this fascinating masterpiece. Ed has demonstrated
a remarkable amount of patience in allowing me to take this long to complete
the review but I see where he came from in asking a fifth-generation
Christian living in Singapore in the middle of Southeast Asia to review a
manuscript on global Christianity by a distinguished Lutheran churchman from
suburban Chicago. This is more than a manuscript, however, it is a collection of
stories, of testimonials, to the grace of an unchanging God in an
ever-changing world.
Lueking begins where it all began, most appropriately in Bethlehem. This
is, however, not the Christmas card Bethlehem of neat roofs, pretty sheep and
shepherds and solitary stars over pastoral scenes of family bliss. It is
the reality of Bethlehem in the here and now, a city that is under military
occupation, in what his first interviewees describe as an "open air prison"
where a Christian Arab was told that "he could die at the side of the road"
by the border guard when his wife tried to take him to the hospital for his
heart attack. Naturally, Lueking asks, "How does one continue to live under
such conditions of injustice and humiliation?" The answer comes from two
veteran Palestinian Lutheran clergymen, Rev. Mitri Raheb and Bishop Munib
Younan, who try to bring about reconciliation between the occupying Israeli
forces and the Christian and Muslim Palestinians who have been living together
for centuries. The answer is in the incarnational life of Christ in these
embattled believers who trust in the Promise Giver even as they strive not to
repay evil with evil but rather bear witness to the Good News that continues
to go from Jerusalem to the ends of the earth.
He moves on to Africa, and for some reason (probably logistic) concentrates
on the eastern part of that vast continent - Kenya, Tanzania and Ethiopia,
as well as the island of Madagascar (not the cartoon jungle!). Kenya is
covered by the remarkable story of a single individual, a young man, a 6 foot 7
refugee from South Sudan who makes contact with the Uhuru Lutheran Church
and is supported by Rev. Lueking's River Forest Church through Pharmacy
school under the mentorship of a Kenyan Lutheran leader. By the time of the
Luekings' second visit to Kenya, this young man has graduated and is returning
to South Sudan to work in an NGO to help others in a similar position to
himself. This is another of the strengths of this book: it provides practical
examples with names and faces of how congregations in the wealthier parts of
the Kingdom of God can make a huge difference in the lives of individuals
living in the two-thirds world. Ethiopia is more comprehensively covered with
stories from the Ethiopian Evangelical Church Mekane Yesus (EECMY), one of
the fastest-growing Lutheran churches in the world. Pastor Geneti Wayessa
talks about the "Ethiopian Bonhoeffer" Gudina Tumsa, the theologian who died
for his faith under the brutal dictatorship of the 1970s. Many Ethiopian
seminarians, both men and women, have their say as they are challenged by
Lueking on issues such as polygamy or living on a $100-a-month pastor's stipend.
Itaffa Gobena, the EECMY President, rounds up the Ethiopian tales with his
own story - one which is typical of the Ethiopians and in fact, of so many
fast-growing church movements throughout Asia and Africa: growing up
nominally Christian, having a "charismatic experience" with healing or speaking in
tongues or some other visible manifestation of the gifts of the Holy Spirit,
persevering through persecution from the Marxists to leading growing
ministries, 100% indigenous. Lueking recounts these stories non-judgmentally, not
attempting to dissect the theology which has torn apart many congregations
nor unquestioningly embracing this rejection of tradition for the
demonstrative and visible form of religion. This comes up again in his discussions with
a church leader in Tanzania who describes "the African cultural" response
to a homosexual parishioner in violent terms that would be unacceptable in
even the most "conservative" parts of the United States. This dispassionate
reporting of "international perspectives" is a little disconcerting at first,
but on second reading, it is probably the only way to be true to the
individuals through whose eyes Lueking seeks to view the Christian world.
Inevitably, AIDS and poverty appear in Tanzania as Lueking spends time with a
missionary and with a Lutheran orphanage. Here, we acknowledge, as the church in
Africa has grown through "signs and wonders" and becomes increasingly
self-supporting and indigenous, there are still huge needs from the twin plagues of
disease and economic devastation that demand far more than the resources of
a young and growing church can provide. However, the "formula" for church
growth in Africa is more than just pioneering missionaries followed by
charismatic renewals. The solid church growth he describes is exemplified by
hundreds of "shepherds," people like Germaine Baolava, a lay woman in
Madagascar who trains for three years for the ministry of word, healing (both
physical and spiritual) prayer and care for the marginalized.
Moving on to Eastern Europe and Russia, Lueking finds seminarians in Russia
who come from all across the vast former empire and share the challenges of
being Lutheran and Russian. He finds Slovak teachers in Lutheran schools
and Lithuanian lay leaders who all shared the horrors of living through
persecution during the Communist era and the challenges of freedom including
nationalism, economics and all the attendant changes that the new era brought.
Moving closer to the heart of Luther-land, Lueking prefaces his sojourn in
Western Europe with the common American tourist comment about beautiful and
empty churches. In spite of this, Lueking finds hope as he describes the
Berlin city mission and a Lutheran nunnery in Darmstadt, among other innovative
ministries of the church in Germany. In Denmark, he quotes a Danish church
leader, Kaj Bollmann, as saying "-Denmark may be viewed as the most secular
place in Europe but don't think of the church here as a lost cause; it is
visible and working in a typically Danish way, modestly, without fanfare about
itself." Similar stories come from Norway where Lueking talks with the
ordained minister who was twice Prime Minister of Norway; Sweden, where church
attendances are hovering at around 2% of the population; and Finland where in
the words of Pastor Olli Valtonen, "Everybody loves the church but nobody
goes there."
He moves next to Central America with a compelling narrative beginning with
the defining point that Lutherans in Central America "bear the marks of
Christ." In El Salvador, the Luekings dine with Medardo Gomez, who was
confirmed by the legendary martyr Bishop Oscar Romero but became a Lutheran minister
because of a family issue, who was persecuted for a Cross. They interact
with Christian Chavarria, a former child soldier; Bishop Victoria Cortez, once
a refugee, now a Lutheran Bishop; a person living with AIDS in Costa Rica;
as well as many other Lutheran lay people and ministers whose faith had
kept them going through the tumultuous 1980s and 1990s.
In Peru and Bolivia, he meets the church responding to poverty, indigenous
cultures, the aftermath of dictatorship (and the trauma of Sep.11, 1973 in
Chile) [Allende assassination. Ed]. Rev. Lueking interacts with both sides
of a divided church in Chile, the faculty of the world's largest Lutheran
University in Brazil with 156,000 students across 13 campuses, workers in
ministries to the neediest in the slums of Brazil, and creative ministries in
Argentina. Here the most intriguing observations are made - how can the church
in Latin America relate to Catholicism even in its most Marian forms and to
Pentecostalism which seems to be sweeping all before it?
He then crosses the globe to Asia, beginning in Japan, where a seminarian
recognizes the preeminence of Jesus Christ while building bridges to Shinto
practitioners, and he meets members of the tiny and aging Lutheran churches
in Japan. He then moves to Korea where Christianity has gone from 0.5% of the
population to more than 40% with mega-churches of both Pentecostal and
Presbyterian varieties. The Lutheran church in Korea is small but reflective and
recognizing its role in this complex modern yet ancient society facing a
nuclear armed brother nation across the demilitarized zone. Next stop is the
world's most populous country, China. Here we discover the Concordia
International School in Shanghai, tolerated by the Communist Chinese authorities.
Conversations follow with seminarians who have gone on to ministry in both
the prosperous coastal cities as well as the rural Chinese countryside. He
visits the famous Tao Fong Shan centre in Hong Kong where a powerful Asian
theology is being crafted in a setting which looks like one of the Shaolin
temples of the kung fu movies. Taiwan, which is home to six different Lutheran
denominations, gets a good overview too, including fascinating accounts of
pastors with both traditional and unusual ministries (to mail order brides!).
India has eleven Lutheran bodies and more than a billion people. Lueking
visits a slum ministry, discusses church politics and gets a flavour of the
diversity of the church and Christian life in South India.
His sojourn in Indonesia begins with the late Armencius Munthe who is no
stranger to the Crossings Community. I had the privilege of sharing a room
with Bishop Munthe at the Crossings Conference a couple of winters ago and
visiting with him and his son at Trinity Theological College in Singapore. I
can attest to the accuracy of Lueking's description of this lively, dynamic
saint of Sumatra. In my own home church, the Lutheran Church of Singapore,
Lueking was able to meet with both our former and current Bishops, who gave
him good insights into some of the challenges and opportunities we face as a
small church body in a fast changing and growing Southeast Asian country.
Next door to us in Malaysia, Lueking again tells fascinating stories ranging
from the Bishop to a Lutheran legislator, among others.
Finally in the last section of the book on Papua New Guinea and Australia,
we get the tribespeople in colourful garb that used to characterize
missionary journey reports of the past. Yet, these are treated with respect and
engaged as they are, and consequently the challenges they face of economic
pressures, AIDS, crime and church conflict come through just as they would
anywhere else. In Australia, at the tail end of the book, most appropriately,
frank, heartfelt conversations are recorded with Australian Lutherans, men and
women, seminarians, pastors and lay people. The realities of a changing and
increasingly secular world are discussed with people who have been in the
mission fields of both rural Papua New Guinea and ultramodern Australia. The
message is the same: people are still in need of Good News whether they are
people who have just left the stone age in Papua New Guinea or the family
vineyard in South Australia, as the Madagascar Christians put it - every
believer is a missionary as the field is so vast.
What is so special about this book? First off, I do not think that there is
anything like it - a tale of the Lutheran Church around the world. It is
not a book of facts and figures. It is a book of stories that are great
reading. There are tales of heroism, tales of woe, tales of hope and tales of
wonder. At the same time, these are stories about us, stories about people who
believed in God and trusted Him with their lives, their families, their
careers and their ministries. They are also stories about our conflicts with
our neighbours - both Christian and non-Christian - as we struggle to witness
in a secular society where economics and information overload dominate, or
in pluralistic religious communities where Christians are an embattled
minority. Within the church, we hear the stories that are so familiar about the
"worship wars," about the fact that the church cannot ignore the "signs and
wonders" movement that has brought rapid growth but huge theological
questions across Asia, Africa and Latin America. We also hear stories about Lutheran
Christians across the world struggling with sexuality and the debates that
accompany those issues. Lueking tells the stories like a storyteller, a bit
like the great Studs Terkel of Chicago. He does not pass judgment, although
you get a hint of where his sympathies lie. At the same time, he provides
quiet insights into how Christians from the richer world can give a little in
partnership with the local churches in the poorest parts of the world and
make a huge difference. He also shows how Christians from the richer world can
learn lessons in faith from our brothers and sisters from across the globe.
There are some minor errors such as describing the "Somoza regime in El
Salvador" [it was in Nicaragua. Ed] and sometimes you wish that there was a
pastoral commentary to some of the reports (in particular some of those from
East Africa or Japan, for example). Otherwise, it is an excellent book and as
someone living in the world described in the book, I wish that all American
Lutherans would be able to see the Lutheran world "Through Our Eyes" nearly
as well as Dean Lueking does.
[Purchase info: In order to keep the book price at $25, Dean is doing much
of the marketing of Through Their Eyes himself. The quickest way to get a
copy is to send him a check for $30 ($5 extra covers postage and handling) to
Dean Lueking, 829 Lathrop Ave, River Forest, IL 60305 with your name and
address. You will have your own copy pronto. In addition, Dean is making a
special offer for book discussion groups: Order a box of 12 copies at $15.00
each (40% discount) and receive free shipping as well. Several pastoral
friends have found such groups beneficial for broadening a global church
awareness. For this offer, please send a check for $180 (12 x $15.00) to the
above address.]